Key Lime

Moist vanilla cake filled and baked with our key lime pie, topped with key lime buttercream and lightly dusted with graham cracker pie crumbs.

  • Single – $3
  • 4 Pack – $10
  • 6 Pack – $15
  • Dozen – 26
  • Custom Decorated – $3.75
  • Mini Cupcakes – $27 / 2 dozen

Related Products

AllClassic FlavorsFlavors of the DaySpring/Summer Seasonal FlavorsFall/Winter Seasonal FlavorsSpecialty Flavors

Chocolate Coconut

Deep chocolate cake, fluffy coconut cream cheese frosting, fresh coconut shavings, and toasted coconut.


Blueberry puree infused Vanilla cake with blueberry preserve swirled buttercream.

Peanut Butter & Jelly

The perfect combination of our vanilla cake filled with strawberry jam, topped with smooth peanut buttercream and a dollop of strawberry jam.

Chocolate Peppermint Bark

Decadent chocolate cake baked with peppermint candy crunches, light mint butter cream and more peppermint candy crunches.

Chocolate Hazelnut

Sophisticated blend of chocolate hazelnut spread and vanilla butter cream crowns our classic chocolate cake, all finished with a subtle drizzle of chocolate sauce.

Chocolate Covered Strawberry

Romantic vanilla-strawberry cake frosted with smooth chocolate buttercream and a dollop of strawberry preserves.

Banana's Foster

Madagascan bourbon vanilla cake with a generous swirl of rich banana brown sugar buttercream, and caramel drizzle.

Chocolate Banana

Our deep chocolate buttercream frosting on top of golden banana cake.


Classic Vanilla cake with not too sweet bubblegum flavored buttercream.


Buttery vanilla cake swirled with a sweet combination of brown sugar, pecans & cinnamon all underneath a swirl of cream cheese frosting.


Just like the cookie favorite...our Madagascan bourbon vanilla cake with subtle cinnamon cream cheese frosting and cookie crumbs.


Fluffy marshmallow butter cream, drizzled with chocolate sauce, and dusted with graham cracker all rests on top of chocolate cake that been filled with marshmallow and baked with a butter graham.

Pumpkin Spice

Moist pumpkin spice cake frosted with smooth cream cheese butter cream and a light dusting of fall spices.

Mocha Toffee Candy

Chocolate cake loaded with toffee chips, mocha butter and a generous dusting of toffee candy pieces.

Chocolate Turtle

Caramel filled chocolate cake baked with pecans, caramel butter cream drizzled with caramel and chocolate sauces, sprinkled with pecan pieces.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Our signature chocolate cake with a chocolate chip cookie baked inside, crowned with decadent chocolate chip cookie dough butter cream frosting.

Apple Pie

Comforting vanilla cake baked with real apple pie filling, a dollop of vanilla buttercream, a light drizzle of caramel and a subtle dusting of cinnamon.

Sweet Potato Cheesecake

Moist sweet potato cake, swirled with cheesecake, rested under cream cheese frosting and dusted with brown sugar.

Strawberry Cheesecake

The perfect pairing of strawberry cake baked with cheesecake and topped with strawberry cream cheese.

Raspberry Lemonade

Buttery-lemon cake, sweet & tart raspberry cream cheese & raspberry drizzle

Pina Colada

A moist coconut cake crowned with a pineapple-coconut cream cheese frosting topped with toasted coconut

Peach Cobbler

Real peach pie filling baked in a vanilla cupcake with a dollop of vanilla buttercream and dusting of cinnamon.

French Toast

Cinnamon/vanilla cake with the best maple cinnamon butter cream frosting


Our golden vanilla cake, filled with marshmallow, topped with smooth orange/vanilla butter cream...taste just like the nostalgic treat of our youth.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

Our signature chocolate cake topped with velvety smooth peanut butter buttercream and peanut butter candies.

Almond Joy

Light almond cake, coconut cream cheese, rich chocolate ganache, toasted coconut and almond crunch topping

Almond Raspberry

Golden almond cake, topped with almond buttercream and raspberry drizzle on top.

Cape Cod Carrot Cake (Monday)

Supremely moist carrot cake loaded with shredded carrots, crushed pineapple, and chopped walnuts topped with our buttery cream cheese frosting.

Palm Beach Coconut (Friday)

A moist coconut cake with an avalanche of cream cheese frosting sprinkled with buttery toasted coconut flakes.

Martha's Vineyard Strawberry

A market fresh treat all year round. Madagascan bourbon vanilla cake layered & topped with bittersweet strawberry buttercream serves as a pedestal for our creamy strawberry frosting.

Baton Rouge Red Velvet Cupcake

Our ultra moist design on the Southern Classic. Made with a rich and smooth scarlet red velvet cake and topped with our melt-in-your-mouth cream cheese frosting.

Charleston Chocolate on Vanilla

A Fresh Bakery favorite. Madagascan bourbon vanilla cake layered and topped with bittersweet chocolate buttercream. A classic confection.